EIGHT SONGS AND ROMANCES (LIEDER UND ROMANZEN) OP. 14
Recording: Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau,
baritone; Daniel Barenboim, piano [DG 449 633-2]
Published
1861
Composed in 1858, this
set is unique in Brahms’s early song output. In contrast to the
three early sets (Opp. 3, 6, and 7), which he gave the more formal
title “Gesänge,” and all but two of which set German romantic
poets, these eight “songs and romances” all lean heavily on the “folk”
idiom. Indeed, all but one of them are to genuine folk texts,
most of which are associated with their own folk melodies. Six of
these are German folk song texts, and one is a translation of a
Scottish border ballad. The one text with an identifiable
original poet (No. 4) is a translation of a thirteenth-century
troubadour song, which is in many ways another version of
folksong. Brahms composed his own melodies for these texts.
Without sacrificing his compositional sophistication, which is
especially evident in some of the harmonies, Brahms successfully
imitates the style of folksong. Years later, he added a piano
part to the original folk melodies of Nos. 1 and 6 in the huge
collection of folksong arrangements assembled near the end of his life,
and also arranged both melodies for chorus. (There are several
other occasions where he both composed his own melody for and arranged
the original melody of a folk song.) There is a connection to the
earlier groups through the last of them, Op. 7. That group
contains two similar idiomatic settings of folk texts (Nos. 4 and
5). The use of the term “songs and romances” consciously sets the
group apart. The word “Romanzen” can also be translated as
“ballads.” Half of the songs are in a strophic form with an
interesting variation used for one or more of the verses or
stanzas. The first three, as well as the fifth, follow this
pattern. Brahms, conscious of the text’s courtly origins, sets
No. 4 more like an “art song” in three-part form. The sixth and
seventh songs are in a simple strophic form while No. 8 is a brief,
eloquent through-composed setting. (Op. 7, which as noted has some
kinship with both this group and with Opp. 3 and 6, also ends with a
very short song.) In addition to sharing a tone of chivalry and
romance, the songs all deal with the theme of separation, in all cases
except No. 3 (which deals with the murder of a beloved knight) a
separation between lovers. The saddest of all is No. 2, where
that separation comes through death. All eight are extremely
elegant, enjoyable, and ingratiating to perform. Strangely, Nos.
5-8 all share titles (but not texts) with songs from later groups (in
the case of No. 6, the title of Op. 48, No. 1 [and Op. 31, No. 3] is
not identical, but extremely similar).